Canadian Electrical Industry News Week

 

Apr 30, 2018

Safety FlukeBy James R. White

With the recent release of the 2018 edition of the NFPA 70E standard, many users are finding it challenging to interpret what it says and prioritize where they should focus their attention. The short answer is that the entire 70E standard is important, not just one chapter, article or section. However, this article highlights 10 changes that the author believes are most important. Here in Part 1: changes 1-5.

  1. New Table 130.5(C), Estimate of the Likelihood of Occurrence of an Arc Flash Incident for ac and dc Systems

This table replaces Table 130.7(C)(15)(A)(a), Arc Flash Hazard Identification for Alternating Current (ac) and Direct Current (dc) Systems in the 2015 70E standard (see figure 1a). In addition to the title and location change, the new Table 130.5(C) in the 2018 standard changed the third column heading from “Arc Flash PPE Required” to “Likelihood of Occurrence”. Section 130.5(C) of the 2018 standard also states that “Table 130.5(C) shall be permitted to be used to estimate the likelihood of occurrence of an arc flash event to determine if additional protective measures are required.” Use of arc flash-rated clothing and PPE is one of the additional protective measures listed (see Figure 1b).


Fluke














Figure 1a

Table 130.7(C)(15)(A)(a) (Partial) NFPA 70E 2015 Edition
Fluke 2














Figure 1b

Table 130.5(C) (Partial) NFPA 70E 2018 Edition

Why the change?

The 70E standard is written for field electrical workers, not for engineers or attorneys, although they may use it. Over the last several cycles, the 70E committee has tried to improve the usability of the standard, especially the arc flash PPE tables, to make it much easier for field electrical workers to use. By moving Table 130.5(C) into the body of the standard it can be used as part of an arc flash risk assessment for both the Table Method and when arc flash warning labels are used.

Bottom line

The new table is useful, but it cannot take the place of experience or expertise. This table should be used cautiously. The person in front of the equipment about to perform a task must determine its suitability and assess the equipment’s condition, including its condition of maintenance, before performing that task. Use of this table is “permitted”, meaning it’s an option — it can be used, but is not mandatory. At the end of Table 130.5(C) it states that to use the table, equipment must be in normal operating condition:

“Equipment condition considered to be ‘normal’ if all of the following circumstances apply:

  • The equipment is properly installed in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations and applicable industry codes and standards.
  • The equipment is properly maintained in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations and applicable industry codes and standards.
  • The equipment is used in accordance with instructions included in the listing and labeling and in accordance with manufacturer’s instructions.
  • Equipment doors are closed and secured.
  • Equipment covers are in place and secured.
  • There is no evidence of impending failure such as arcing, overheating, loose or bound equipment parts, visible damage, or deterioration.”

Be sure also to read and understand the note (*) at the end of the table that states, in part:

“The estimate of the likelihood of occurrence contained in this table does not cover every possible condition or situation, nor does it address severity of injury or damage to health. Where this table identifies “No” as an estimate of likelihood of occurrence, it means that an arc flash incident is not likely to occur. Where this table identifies “Yes” as an estimate of likelihood of occurrence, it means that additional protective measures are required to be selected and implemented according to the hierarchy of risk control identified in 110.1(H).”

Be aware that “Not likely to occur” does not mean it won’t happen. It just means there is a reduced risk of occurrence. Use your best judgement, in addition to this table, when assessing risk.

  1. DC voltage shock threshold changed back to 50V

This threshold was changed back to 50V from 100V to comply with OSHA regulations.

Why the change?

In the 2015 70E review cycle, the shock threshold for dc volts was changed to 100 Vdc (see Figure 2a) after a majority the 70E committee was convinced to do so by a very convincing dissertation from a well-respected speaker.

Fluke 3













Figure 2a

Table 130.4(D)(b) (Partial) NFPA 70E 2015 Edition

Although technically, the speaker was correct, OSHA didn’t agree with him. So during the 2018 review cycle OSHA distributed a letter of interpretation to the committee, dated September 4, 2015, stating that OSHA would cite any employer who did not observe its 50 Vac or Vdc threshold. The letter included examples where workers had been killed by voltages under 50 V. Based on the input from OSHA, the committee reversed its stance on the shock threshold and went back to the 50 Vdc value (see Figure 2b).



Fluke 4






Figure 2b

Table 130.4(D)(b) (Partial) NFPA 2018 Edition

Bottom line

The shock threshold for ac and dc voltages is once again 50 V to comply with OSHA regulations. This is based on a section of the Foreword in the 70Estandard that states, “The committee would develop a standard for electrical installations that would be compatible with the OSHA requirements for employee safety…”

  1. New Table 130.5(G), Selection of Arc-Rated Clothing and Other PPE When the Incident Energy Analysis Method Is Used

In the 2018 70E standard, Table 130.5(G) replaces Table H.3(b) from the 2015 standard. The new table provides guidance on how to select PPE when using the incident energy analysis method and was moved to the body of the standard.

Why the change?

In previous editions of the 70E standard, Table H.3(b) (see Figure 3a) was located in Informative Annex H. Workers commented that there was no method for selecting all the PPE required when using the incident energy analysis method, because Table H.3(b) was in Annex H and anything in the annexes is not considered part of the standard. As a result, Table H.3(b) was not being used as intended. In the 2018 70E the table was modified to eliminate any clothing or PPE under 1.2 cal/cm2, because it only deals with arc-rated clothing and other PPE. The table was renamed Table 130.5(G) and put into the body of the standard. Its use is “permitted”, meaning it’s an option — it can be used, but is not mandatory.
Fluke 5
















Figure 3a

Table H.3(b) (Partial) NFPA 70E 2015 Edition

 

Fluke 6










 

Figure 3b

Table 130.5(G) (Partial) NFPA 70E 2018 Edition

Bottom line

If arc-rated clothing and PPE are to be selected using arc flash warning labels, Table 130.5(G) can be used to assist in choosing arc-rated and other PPE. Users are cautioned not to mix the Table Method with the incident energy analysis method for selecting their arc-rated clothing and PPE. The two methods are not compatible and could cause issues. The Table Method is used when estimating the available fault current and operating time of the overcurrent protective device (OCPD). Table 130.5(G) is used when the equipment has arc flash warning labels on it.

  1. 70E Committee sets minimum CPR and First Aid training intervals.

The 2018 70E edition now states in 110.2(C)(2)(d), “Training shall occur at a frequency that satisfies the requirements of the certifying body.” Thus the 70E committee sets minimum requirements for CPR and First Aid training, not best safe work practices.

Why the change?

In previous editions of the 70E, CPR, First Aid, and AED training were required annually. This may have been more frequent than the requirements set by various organizations (such as the American Heart Association (AHA), for the general public, but electrical workers face a much greater risk from ventricular fibrillation due to shock than the general public.

During the 2018 70E review cycle the issue came up that the 70E does not set best safe work practices; it sets minimum requirements. Companies are to meet or exceed the requirements in the 70E.

Bottom line

The idea of the 70E standard setting minimum standards vs. best safe work practices has been the subject of several discussions among committee members in the past. In general, the committee has voted to establish that the 70E standard indeed sets minimum requirements, not best safe work practice. As part of that approach, the standard states that the training interval requirement follows that of the certifying body. For example, if the American Heart Association’s interval for recertification is two years, that is the new requirement from the 70E. However, as a practical matter workers are probably not going to remember how to perform CPR or first aid under the stresses of an emergency situation, knowing that someone’s life could hang in the balance, after more than a year. So the author strongly recommends annual training for CPR, first aid, and/or AED use (if an AED is available at the work site.)

  1. Forget the 40 cal/cm2 incident energy threshold

Incident energy is not a good measure of the pressure wave that might be created by an arc event. The committee did not want workers to think that an arc event under 40 cal/cm2 was not serious.

Why the change?

In previous editions, the 70E contained an informational note in 130.7(A) that stated, “When incident energy exceeds 40 cal/cm2 at the working distance, greater emphasis may be necessary with respect to de-energizing when exposed to electrical hazards.” This was the “line in the sand” companies and workers used to determine what was safe and what could not be worked on. However, that is not what the Informational note said. It stated only that extra efforts should be made to de-energize equipment, not that it could not be worked on. In general, most people would say that equipment rated above 40 cal/cm2 is off limits. I’m good with that.

The problem with that informational note is that it was created during the 2000 review cycle. Our understanding of arc flash and arc blast has changed considerably since then. There are situations when incident energy below 40 cal/cm2 might be more hazardous than when it is above that level. For example, a fault that releases 40 cal/cm2 over 30 cycles will create less arc pressure than one that releases its energy in two cycles, all things being equal. We now know that pressure wave (arc blast) is related to the fault current, not incident energy, because it is an instantaneous event.

Bottom line

There is no such thing as a “safe” arcing fault. Incident energy is not a good measure of the pressure wave that might be created by an arc. Equipment rated above 40 cal/cm2 should be de-energized before being worked on. But equipment rated below that level should be because an arc event under 40 cal/cm2 can be serious as well.

Author’s note

This 2-part article only touches on some of the revisions to the 2018 edition of NFPA 70E. Many recurring or global changes are not covered here. The NFPA 70E committee reviews the actions it has taken in the past, then tries to improve what is written to make the 70E as clear and usable for the field service technician as possible. It is up to the user to interpret the 70E and apply it in the workplace. The author suggests that each user visit the NFPA 70E page and review the actions and committee statements for each action. These provide even more insight into why the committee took a specific action and the intent of that action.

James R. White is Vice President of Training Services, Shermco Industries for Fluke Corp.

Watch for Part 2 in an upcoming issue of EIN.

Image source: Graphic Products

 

 

 

 

 

Changing Scene

  • Prev
This month, IDEAL is challenging competitors to draw an Electrical Power One-Line Diagram ...
EngWorks Inc. and the Alberta Electrical Alliance have announced a strategic partnership as of May ...
David Collie, ESA’s President & CEO, signs the new Leadership Accord, proudly committed to ...
Electro-Federation Canada (EFC) represents electrical and automation manufacturers, distributors ...
Demand for electric vehicles in Canada keeps increasing; 68% of Canadians will consider ...
ESA is warning on potential electrical hazards associated with the replacement of metallic water ...
The Canadian Apprenticeship Forum (CAF-FCA) has released its latest labour market information ...
The Ontario government is introducing new measures to help tradespeople get their certification ...
This ECAA Annual Training Day & AGM hybrid event will take place May 27th – May 29th. ...
Technical Safety BC has reviewed the 2021 Canadian Electrical Code (CE Code) to assess the impacts ...


 

ABB RoboticsABB Robotics is driving automation in the construction industry with new robotic automation solutions to address key challenges, including the need for more affordable and environmentally friendly housing and to reduce the environmental impact of construction, amidst a labor and skills shortage.

Robotic automation offers huge potential to enhance productivity, efficiency and manufacturing flexibility throughout the construction industry, including automating the fabrication of modular homes and building components off-site, robotic welding and material handling on building sites and robot 3D printing of houses and customized structures. 



Read More


 

Canadian Electrical Contractor Discussion Group: Can You Count the Deficiencies?

EIN CECD 400Have you ever been called to fix the work of a 'handyman'?

"Was supposedly done by a"certified ' electrician....told the homeowner that he got a $266 permit....no record at TSBC. Can you count the deficiencies?"

"There is a second panel change in the triplex also.......even more deficiencies. Think the guy was a glorified handyman. Ones not obvious: 240 BB heat hooked up 120....drier on 2p20....range on 2p50....water heater fed with 2c14 Bx on 2p15."

Go HERE to join the discussion

 


 

Smart GridHarnessing Canada’s immense clean energy resources requires transformational investments to modernize our electricity grid. The Government of Canada is investing in renewable energy and upgrading the electricity grid to make clean, affordable electricity options more accessible in communities across Canada.

The Honourable Seamus O’Regan Jr., Minister of Natural Resources, today launched a $964-million program to support smart renewable energy and grid modernization projects that will lower emissions by investing in clean energy technologies, like wind, solar, storage, hydro, geothermal and tidal.

Read More

 


 



Trilliant Partners with the City of CowansvilleThe City of Cowansville in south-central Quebec is the largest city in the Brome-Missisquoi region, with more than 15,000 residents. Despite being a smaller-sized city, it is known as an economic and industrial hub.

It also has a strong focus on innovation and efficiency — as demonstrated by decisions such as the one it made in 2017 to use beet juice to help combat icy winter roads, allowing the City to reduce the amount of salt it was using, thereby saving money and decreasing the impact on the environment. 

 

 

Read More


 

Keith SonesBy Keith Sones

The writing was on the wall.  The closures would happen. But a lot of people were upset, and I was one of them. 

In the early 2000s, my family and I were living in a mainly rural (at least by city dweller standards) valley in south central British Columbia.  The West Kootenay region is known for its diverse outdoor recreation activities and as a great place to raise a family.  It has a proud industrial history, evidenced through the longstanding pulp mill, a massive lead zinc smelter a few miles away and several hydroelectric dams, all of it within spitting distance of the mighty Columbia River. 

Read More


 

Product News

  • Prev
6 functions in one pair of pliers. Multifunctional pliers for the electrical installation; to grip ...
With the ABB StarTeck® selector web app you can match cables with Teck fittings quickly and easily. ...
WPS Gen 4 wall pack series is a classic and familiar design integrated with modern LED technology ...
These new controllers offer indoor or outdoor ON/OFF, photocell, dimming, scene and color tuning ...
Eaton’s broad selection of Wi-Fi smart devices offer reliability with unbeatable ease of setup. ...
Albeo® ABV3 luminaires can be ordered with an integrated Daintree Wireless WHS20 sensor for a range ...
Lumenpulse has announced the release of two additional smaller sizes of the Lumenquad, a ...
Milwaukee’s 2-Layer Face Mask is designed to be lightweight and breathable. This MILWAUKEE® face ...
Wiha Insulated SoftFinish® Cushion Grip Pliers and Cutters are the standard for premium quality ...
Ideal for rough service applications, the A19 & PAR Series are engineered for high efficiency, ...

 

Lumenquad New VersionsLumenpulse has announced the release of two additional smaller sizes of the Lumenquad, a rectilinear projector for both outdoor and indoor environments. Developed for architectural applications such as lighting landscapes, highlighting details, pathways and monuments, the Lumenquad Small and Medium are compact, low-wattage, high-performance projectors, complementing the two existing products in the family.

The Lumenquad Small and Medium are the latest additions to a family of sleek, elegant, high-performance projectors that has already been validated with honours, including recognition in the PIA Awards in 2019, together with a Lux Awards for Exterior Luminaire of the Year in 2019. 

Read More


 

 

Wiha Lineman's Pliers and CrimpersWiha Insulated SoftFinish® Cushion Grip Pliers and Cutters are the standard for premium quality featuring ergonomic cushion grip handles for comfort and control, dual durometer construction for long-lasting durability, and handles directly molded to the tool steel for a permanent bond.

The grips feature a slip guard handle design for added protection at the front-end and raised rear-finger steps for easy opening at the back-end. Wiha Insulated SoftFinish® Cushion Grip Pliers and Cutters consist of premium quality tool steel for strength and durability and induction hardened cutting edges and jaws for superior sharpness and longevity. 

Read More


 

 

eLumigen Poultry Lamps - 2000K, 3000K & 5000KIdeal for rough service applications, the A19 & PAR Series are engineered for high efficiency, vibration resistance, shatter-resistance, elevated heat environments, and wet locations. These dimmable LED Lamps help reduce energy costs, labor costs, and the headaches of frequent lamp changes in tough applications.

eLumigen employs a unique 21-point validation process that goes above and beyond industry standards. Our lamps have been tested to survive levels of vibration exceeding 20G forces. Our unique temperature foldback design improves both safety and thermal management of our lamps. 

Read More


 

Peers & Profiles

  • Prev
From small construction to sophisticated industrial projects, House of Electrical Supplies has been ...
Kyle Manfredi is the owner of ARK Electrical alongside his wife, Shannon. Operating out of ...
Like most major events over the last year, the COVID-19 pandemic put serious restrictions on the ...
This past December Jennifer Green was honoured with Canada’s Most Powerful Women Top 100 Award for ...
“It was quite surprising,” said Stephanie Smith of being named EHRC’s Leader of the Year. ...
As an advanced networked lighting controls company serving the industrial and large commercial ...
Trilliant, an international provider of utility solutions for advanced metering and smart grid ...
For more than a century, ABB has been investing in Canadian technologies and products to support ...
Mackenzie Gillan, a bright young lady from Baysville, Ontario, tells us about how she learned ...
Energy Efficient Lighting is a LED lighting manufacturer with nearly 30 years of industry ...


House of Electrical SuppliesFrom small construction to sophisticated industrial projects, House of Electrical Supplies has been servicing clients in the industrial, OEM, entertainment, and construction markets across the Greater Toronto Area for just over 40 years. The company has earned a reputation for providing a high-quality customer experience.

As per President Austin Brennan, their experienced and knowledgeable team can be depended upon in any situation to deliver quick and efficient service. On top of their product solutions — ranging from electrical, automation, safety, lighting and portable power distribution — 

Read More


 

Copper $US Dollar price per pound

Kerrwil Publications Great Place to Work. Certified December 2019 - December 2020

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2021 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil