Comparing LED and HID Horticultural Luminaires

Horticulture

 

May 28, 2018

An evaluation of the energy and economic performance of LED horticultural luminaires compared with high-pressure sodium (HPS) and metal halide (MH) horticultural luminaires has found that the LEDs cannot replace HPS luminaires on a one-for-one basis while still maintaining the original photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD).

The evaluation was conducted by the Lighting Research Center (LRC) at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, and funded in part by Natural Resources Canada. Based on findings from a literature review and online survey conducted by the LRC in 2016, the project team developed a framework for evaluating and comparing horticultural luminaires. The framework includes recommended testing, evaluation, and reporting methods. It allows luminaires to be compared based on equal PPFD. PPFD for plants is analogous to photopic illuminance on a work surface in an architectural application. The framework includes an analysis of 11 luminaire-specific metrics and 5 application-specific metrics, which provide growers with the best available information regarding any given horticultural luminaire’s performance.

The LRC then used this framework to test and evaluate 13 horticultural luminaires, including 10 LED, 2o HPS, and one MH product.* First, the LRC photometrically tested individual luminaires. Then the LRC modelled the use of the luminaires in a simulated greenhouse to assess the number of luminaires and the lighting system energy requirements necessary to reach minimum PPFD and uniformity criteria.

The results show that intensity distribution plays an important role, illustrated by the fact that two of the tested LED luminaires had higher luminaire efficacy than the HPS luminaires but still had a higher total power demand in the greenhouse application.

The LRC found an increase in shading from LED luminaires compared with HPS luminaires due to the size of the luminaires and the fact that more are needed to provide the same PPFD in a greenhouse. The shading from LED luminaires reduces daylight in a greenhouse by 13% to 55% compared with a 5% reduction in daylight from HPS luminaires, thus more electric energy could be needed for lighting with the LED systems, depending upon the available daylight.

The greater number of LED luminaires and their equivalency, on average, in application power demand impacted their life-cycle costs. The LRC found that three of the tested LED horticultural luminaire lighting systems had lower life-cycle costs and the remaining seven had higher life-cycle costs than either of the two 1000-watt HPS lighting systems that were tested.

The results of the evaluation show that stakeholders can be misled by considering luminaire efficacy alone. Rather, the luminaire intensity distribution and layout to reach a criterion PPFD are necessary for an accurate life cycle cost analysis. The LRC report provides a technology-neutral framework that stakeholders can use to evaluate lighting systems.

The project was funded by the Lighting Energy Alliance and Natural Resources Canada. Members of the Lighting Energy Alliance include Efficiency Vermont, Energize Connecticut, National Grid, and the Northwest Energy Efficiency Alliance.

View the report

This article is a lightly edited version of the report’s introduction.

Photo source: Philips Lighting

* The results in this report are based on electrical and photometric testing of one luminaire sample per model. Life testing was not conducted for this project. No crops were grown or evaluated with any of the tested luminaires.

Related Articles


Latest Articles


Changing Scene

  • Saskatchewan Investing in Skills Training

    Saskatchewan Investing in Skills Training

    March 28, 2025 Guided by Building the Workforce for a Growing Economy: the Saskatchewan Labour Market Strategy, the Ministry of Immigration and Career Training is investing more than $117.0 million in programs and services. “We continue to make training available for Saskatchewan people to prepare for the record number of jobs being created by our growing… Read More…

  • New Skilled Trades and Technology Building for the New Saskatchewan Polytechnic Joseph A. Remai Saskatoon Campus Proceeding to Request for Proposals

    New Skilled Trades and Technology Building for the New Saskatchewan Polytechnic Joseph A. Remai Saskatoon Campus Proceeding to Request for Proposals

    March 28, 2025 Three teams are advancing to the next stage of procurement for the new Skilled Trades and Technology building for the Saskatchewan Polytechnic, Joseph A. Remai Saskatoon Campus. Upon procurement completion, the successful proponent will be awarded the design and construction of the new Trades building under a Design-Build agreement.  “This project is… Read More…

  • New Brunswick Legislation Introduced to Support Interprovincial Labour Mobility

    New Brunswick Legislation Introduced to Support Interprovincial Labour Mobility

    March 28, 2025 The New Brunswick government has introduced legislative amendments to improve labour mobility and reduce interprovincial barriers. “With potential tariff-related disruptions and an uncertain economic climate, workers and businesses need the ability to adapt quickly to quickly changing circumstances,” said Jean-Claude D’Amours, acting minister of post-secondary education, training and labour. “A flexible and… Read More…

  • New Brunswick Electric Vehicle Incentive Will End July 1

    New Brunswick Electric Vehicle Incentive Will End July 1

    March 28, 2025 The New Brunswick provincial government will end its Electric Vehicle Incentive Program on July 1. “This rebate program made it possible for many New Brunswickers to buy an electric vehicle during their introduction to the market, and is helping reduce greenhouse gas emissions,” said Finance and Treasury Board Minister René Legacy, who… Read More…