Canadian Electrical Industry News Week

Sept 3, 2020

LightingBy Steve Mesh

All dimmers are created equal, right? Wrong! All drivers are created equal, right? Wrong!

It’s not sufficient to say that you want fixtures to be “dimmable.” There have always been variations in how different dimmers work, and fluorescent ballasts, and more recently LED drivers. Now this is even more complicated because you can use fixtures that also allow you to change colouration, but that’s a subject that we’ll leave for a subsequent post.

Specificity is the soul of narrative, but it is also the soul of specifying luminaires and lighting controls. It behooves you as a specifier or installer (or anyone else involved in the process of procurement, installation or commissioning) to be specific about your expectations with regard to how the lighting and control equipment works. Let’s talk about dimming and dimming curves, and a variety of attributes that you should consider, inquire about, then specify what you actually want. These include the relationship of the slider position (as in the case of a slide dimmer), measured light output, perceived light output, and even resulting power draw. Who knew that a simple wallbox dimmer could be so complicated?

Non-lighting experts may assume that there’s a direct relationship between the position of a slider (as in the case of a slide wallbox dimmer) and the light level. However, most lighting experts know that some dimmers are designed to compensate for how the eye reacts to changes in light levels. Therefore, a “linear” reduction in the slider’s position on the dimmer may result in what’s called “square-law dimming.” A “linear” dimmer paired with a “logarithmic” (“square-law”) LED driver will give you this result. That’s also true if you pair a “logarithmic” (“square-law”) dimmer with a “linear” driver.

Based on that example, you can see that the result is based on the “input” (let’s say the slider position in the case of a wallbox dimmer) and what the message is that the dimmer sends to the driver. But it is also based on the pairing of the input device (i.e., a wallbox dimmer) with the device it’s controlling (i.e., an LED driver). There are some typical dimming curves that manufacturers tend to use in terms of input and output devices:

1. linear
2. logarithmic (sometimes referred to as “square-law”)
3. “S”

For example, a dimmer with a linear curve in terms of slider position will send a signal to a driver to reduce light output by 50% if you pull the slider down halfway. To the eye, this will appear substantially brighter than 50%. On the other hand, if you pair a linear dimmer with a with a driver that’s designed for square-law (or what is commonly referred to as logarithmic) output, then pulling the slider halfway down will send a signal to the driver to dim to 25% of full output — but it will be perceived by the human eye as 50%. Therefore, in that situation this specific dimmer/driver pairing means that what you perceive matches the slider position. The measured light output, however, does not, nor will the power draw match the slider position.

Linear/linear

A linear/linear combination — meaning a linear dimmer paired with a linear driver — is typically adequate when you’re using dimming largely to achieve energy savings. It’s common for drivers designed primarily for energy savings to be dimmable down to 20% of full output (or in some cases to 10%). These are often marketed as energy-saving products. For example, if the target light level in an office was 40 footcandles on desks, then 20% of that would be 8 footcandles. It’s unlikely that most occupants would want to work with less than 8 footcandles on their desk! Therefore, using a “20%” LED driver is perfectly adequate. Since the point of using these products in that application is mostly to save energy, it’s not really problematic that the perceived light level will not necessarily match the slider position.

Linear/logarithmic

As previously explained, you can pair a linear dimmer with a logarithmic driver, or vice versa. Both combinations accomplish the same thing. These pairings result in what’s typically called “square-law dimming” as previously explained. This provides output that is adjusted based on how the eye perceives light levels — not based on what is read on the light meter. This type of pairing makes better use of the entire range of slider positions, especially at the lower end of the light output range. Obviously, you can now see why it’s important to specify (and verify) what type of dimming curve the dimmer (or lighting control system) puts out, and what type the output device such as an LED driver is designed to provide. If you don’t specify (and then verify) this, how will you know that you are truly getting a linear/logarithmic pairing that will provide square-law dimming? It should also be noted that these are typically referred to as architectural products. As such, they are typically designed to dim to 1% of full output, or in some cases even less.

Because of the square-law nature of correlating measured light output with perceived light output, an energy-saving product designed with a low-end value of 20% would result in a perceived light output of about 45%. There are many architectural situations where that doesn’t cut the mustard. For example, imagine a ballroom where you may want to have a very low level of ambient light, possibly supplemented by other specialized fixtures providing drama, colour, patterns, projections, etc. You would certainly want/need to achieve very low ambient levels that require going way below a 20% measured light value. The same would apply to any space used for audio-visual presentations. It would also make sense for certain rooms in a residential setting — especially the dining room, living room, etc.

Perceived VS. Measured Light

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Image courtesy of Pathway Lighting

Logarithmic/logarithmic

If you pair a logarithmic dimmer with a logarithmic driver (both designed for square-law dimming), you’ll end up with a much more exaggerated curve for the output of the LED fixture. This means that most of the dimming will occur at the top end of the slider travel, and there will be a much larger range of the slider position below that, which will give you lots of control over the lower range of light output. If that’s desirable in a certain space, then you now know that you must specify both logarithmic dimmers as well as drivers that operate according to square-law dimming curves. However, this isn’t typically desirable in most applications.

Linear and Logarithmic

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Image courtesy of EldoLED

Other curves

You can design a dimmer (input device) or driver (output device) to follow specific curves of your own desire. There are in fact other types of curves that various vendors have devised, such as “S” curves, “soft linear” curves, etc. Some theatrical dimming systems and fixtures have other preprogrammed curves as well. These are usually designed to provide more controllability in specific parts of the input (i.e., slider) range. Some theatrical fixtures actually allow you to select the type of dimming curve you want by cycling through options right at the fixture itself. However, manufacturers of architectural products tend to adhere to either linear or logarithmic for both input as well as output devices — and that gives you the kinds of results previously described.

Linear, Square Law, S-Curve and Tungsten









Image courtesy of Rosco


Watch for Part 2 of this article in an upcoming issue.

[IT]Steve Mesh is an award-winning lighting designer who has designed lighting and control systems for a variety of project types (commercial, museums, schools, residential, restaurants, retail, historic, healthcare, etc.). As an educator, he has taught classes and given presentations about lighting and controls across North America and internationally. One of his is developing lighting and lighting controls courses that rely on hands-on and/or interactive content. He has been a repeat speaker at LightFair for many years.

Published with the permission of Lighting Control Association.


      Salex Welcomes New Partner: Senso by Lumini                    

LDS Salex Spotlight 400Salex is pleased to announce a new partnership with Senso by Luminii – a Canadian manufacturer of locally made LED fixtures. As of August 6, Salex will represent their lighting products in the Southwestern Ontario region.

With every product, Senso Lighting pursues a vision of providing flexible and environmentally conscious lighting solutions to upgrade the typical fluorescent office. For over ten years, the Canadian manufacturer has specialized in LED technology and embarks on a mission to illuminate commercial spaces with custom solutions that are beautiful, economical and sustainable.


READ MORE


 

Changing Scene

  • Prev
InfraCanada / InfraQuebec is an annual series of user group meetings across Canada for FLIR and ITC ...
IDEAL has a long history of offering collectible toy trucks, which have always been a popular item ...
In celebration of National Women’s History Month, the Canadian Apprenticeship Forum (CAFFCA) is ...
Hubbell Canada manufacturer of Electrical and Lighting products announces a significant step ...
Join ESA on Zoom for their first webinar of the fall, Electrically Safe Work ...
Being able to quickly adjust to the unexpected is a big part of any construction project, but solar ...
Rob McKinney will present on "The Eight Steps to Digitize Construction Workflow" during this ...
CE Pro announced the winners of the 2020 CE Pro BEST (Best Electronics Systems Technologies) ...
Nexans Canada has launched a service providing cable reel tracking via connected devices. The ...
The Manitoba government has expanded its Back to Work in Manitoba Wage Subsidy Program as part ...


#IDEALTruckinIDEAL has a long history of offering collectible toy trucks, which have always been a popular item with electricians and contractors, So they are very excited to announce our 2020 promotion, Keep on Truckin’ with IDEAL.

This fall, participating distributors will receive two 1:24 scale, diecast Dodge RAM® 1500 pickup trucks, complete with IDEAL branding, to raffle to their customers. The toy trucks will also be available as a premium to end-users who make a qualifying purchase of a barrel of Can-Twist™ Wire Connectors during the promo period.

 

Read More


 

Connected Drum Internet of Things Nexans Canada has launched a service providing cable reel tracking via connected devices. The “Connected Drum” Internet of Things (IoT) service allows customers to benefit from real-time location, theft and loss detection and management of residual cable lengths on reels. 

By tracking and monitoring a fleet of cable reels that are off-site or at subcontractor locations, significant savings can be realized. The service includes an online and mobile software platform for efficient and convenient management. This innovation provides customers with the real-time location of each reel as well as an alert system for monitoring on-site events including deliveries and pick-ups.

Read More


 

 

ManitobaThe Manitoba government has expanded its Back to Work in Manitoba Wage Subsidy Program as part of its continued commitment to safely restarting the provincial economy.

“The Back to Work wage subsidy is benefiting hundreds of Manitoba businesses that are bringing back employees who were laid off during the COVID-19 pandemic, and hiring more staff to boost their operations and provide valued services to Manitobans,” said Manitoba Premier Brian Pallister. “Manitoba has designed some of Canada’s strongest support programs to help relieve small businesses of unexpected financial burdens...

Read More


 



Terry BeckerBy Terry Becker

We are quickly approaching January 2021 and publication of the 5th edition of the CSA Z462 Workplace electrical safety Standard. This is good news for Canada as we continue to evolve in our identification and management of the electrical hazards of arc flash and shock.

But as I have quoted in the past, we need to ensure we are getting it right, and there is still a lot of work to be done. Most of the focus has been on arc flash and I am concerned that the electric shock hazard has been neglected.

Read More


 

Product News

  • Prev
Avoid the trouble caused from tripped circuit breakers with Eaton's Energy Management System (EMS), ...
FLIR Systems, Inc. (NASDAQ: FLIR) today announced four new additions to its Exx-Series of advanced ...
Provides extra depth to Type 1 screw cover junction boxes - for use with CS, CSG, CSKO, CSKOG ...
Leviton has a new line of LEV Series IEC 60309-1 and IEC 60309-2 Pin & Sleeve devices with ...
Discover the new compact MV Switchgear featuring SF6-free Shielded Solid Insulation (2SIS) and ...
Dual voltage panel consists of back side panel equipped with 480/600 VAC breakers and Plug & ...
FLIR Systems, Inc. recently announced four new additions to its Exx-Series of advanced thermal ...
LanXPLORER Pro is a tester for analyzing and diagnosing problems in networks, cabling, and ...
Skilled labor shortages and compressed project timelines can be tough on contractors. Vive ...
Stanpro’s new I series of industrial remotes are ideal for applications requiring maximum ...


 

Mersen IsoMAXXMersen is pleased to introduce its high performance IsoMAXX Vacuum Brazed Cold Plates. This patented design is the optimum cooling solution for latest generation PrimePACK IGBTs. IsoMAXX represents a super compact cooling solution providing unsurpassed cooling performance with a high degree of thermal homogeneity on chip-to-chip and module-to-module configurations.

As market needs for more efficient electrical power conversion designs grow, so do the technological advancements from power electronic module manufacturers. The new generation of PrimePACK IGBT modules now boast an increased power dissipation compared to previous generations. 

Read More


 

Betacalo Soft SQThe optimally engineered diffuser throws the light downwards exactly where it is required, while creating a subtle indirect glow on the ceiling. Ideally suited for atriums, lobbies, boardrooms and reception areas.

Body: Aluminum and steel.

Diffuser: Opal acrylic.

Drivers: HPF electronic for 120-277V (EU-240V)

Remote mounting of drivers: Wire Size (max distance from canopy to drivers) 18 AWG - 9.5' (2.9m), 16 AWG - 19.5' (5.9m), 14 AWG - 29.5' (9m). Drivers must be accessible after installation.  

Read More


 

Peers & Profiles

  • Prev
For more than a century, ABB has been investing in Canadian technologies and products to support ...
Mackenzie Gillan, a bright young lady from Baysville, Ontario, tells us about how she learned ...
Energy Efficient Lighting is a LED lighting manufacturer with nearly 30 years of industry ...
Dee Durant is an industrial electrician apprentice attending Conestoga College and an Ambassador ...
ECAO recently launched a new program called Future Leaders Advisory Council (FLAC). Their inaugural ...
At 14, Tom Miguel was sitting in the counselor’s office of Silverthorn Collegiate Institute in ...
Meredith Halfpenny is a Wind Site Technician with Boralex where she inspects, maintains, and ...
Rutul Bhavsar is a final year Electrical Engineering student at Mohawk College. He recently ...
Shannon Tymosko is a first-year apprentice with IBEW (International Brotherhood of Electrical ...
ELG Electric is an electrical contractor based out of Goderich, Ontario serving the area’s ...

Dee DurantDee Durant is an industrial electrician apprentice attending Conestoga College and an Ambassador for Kick Ass Careers. As an ambassador for KickAss Careers she spent time shadowing mentor and KickAss founder Jamie McMillan attending events for the organization.

The advancement of women in male dominated industries is an important endeavor for Durant, inspired by her mother, who was the first woman on the Brantford Police department. In EIN's interview with Durant, she discussed the future of electrical work, and how the ongoing pandemic is affecting our country’s students.

Read More


 

EE LightingBy Blake Marchand

Energy Efficient Lighting is a LED lighting manufacturer with nearly 30 years of industry experience. One that was founded on principles of environmental sustainability and responsibility to future generations. Based out of Markham, Ontario, they offer complete lighting solutions for commercial and industrial applications.

Their product lines include conventional lighting fixtures, LED retrofit kits, complete LED luminaires, LED systems, drivers and electronic ballasts. 

 

Read More


 

Copper $US Dollar price per pound

Kerrwil Publications Great Place to Work. Certified December 2019 - December 2020

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2020 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil