Canadian Electrical Industry News Week

 July 13, 2018

Safety 2By Alfred Mörx

Taking adequate measures when planning and making equipment (e.g., low‐voltage switchgear assemblies) ensures that any risk that remains after the application of protective measures is as low as possible. Part 1 explored the relationship between risk and safety, seven reasons for implementing safety precautions, consequential damage, and its costs. Here in Part 2 of 3: consequential damage and its costs.

System protection and consequential damages

Installation‐specific consequential damages can be detected with the help of the damage interruption function. Recovery costs, e.g., of the low‐voltage switchgear assemblies and damaged system parts, must always be added.

The damage interruption function, also referred to as customer damage function, can be defined as the functional connection between the emerging damage in an electrical installation during failure of the installation(or during its restricted operation) and the duration of interruption.

The function can show points of discontinuity if damage to the means of production occurs when a specific value of the duration of interruption is exceeded. A good example would be preparations (e.g., food) which can no longer be further processed after a specific duration of process interruption and must be thrown away.

Detecting system‐specific damage interruption function

Consequential damages in the case of power failure can only be ascertained system‐specifically with sufficient accuracy because of the major differences in the use of the installations.

Additionally, knowledge of the consequential damages, as expressed through the damage interruption function, is also important for the interpretation of possible necessary backup power energy distribution systems. Also these backup power energy distribution systems with their switchgear assemblies and the switchgear built in them must in many cases meet higher requirements than the minimum requirements stipulated in the generally accepted technical standards.

For the detection of specific system‐specific Damage Interruption Functions from Damage Interruption Functions of more or less similar supply interruptions, detailed calculation concepts are available today (see [5] and therein cited literature).

Already on the basis of the incomplete overview provided in the chart below, consequential damages, upon using the respective company‐specific data, can be calculated for a specific electric system and compared with the costs for any additional constructive measures for the installation of the system.

To calculate the total damage (e.g., after a complete or partial destruction of low‐voltage switchgear assemblies or system parts), add recovery costs (e.g., of the low‐voltage switchgear assemblies and damaged system parts).

Safety 1

















Examples from the area of supply of information technological equipment

Low‐voltage switchgear assemblies that support IT equipment, that support business processes or such that manage the business process must always be carefully considered regarding their failure safety. In many cases, “only standard‐compliant switchgear” is not enough.

System failures in this type of plant can cause considerable consequential damage, even when the period of interruption is only a few hours.

In [07], the following information can be found for IT equipment (already in 2007!):

“The costs for lost working time as result from hourly rate and number of concerned employees can always provide a very rough idea because other factors are usually more important:

  • possibly, contractual penalties for untimely deliveries are to be paid, which is common practice in the automotive industry today
  • direct downtime costs also include any damage through loss of reputation that is difficult to quantify, like angry customers and suppliers

The more business processes depend on IT, the more seldom it will be that the consequences of IT system downtime are minor. For instance, 10 years ago you could at least still phone. Today, telephone exchanges are also integrated into IT today; at the same time, with e‐mail, part of communication has shifted directly to IT.”

A rough evaluation of the costs for the non‐usability of IT equipment for a few branches is summarized below.

[PLEASE INSERT EIN-20-Safety-1.jpg HERE]

Consequential damages per hour in the case of downtime of IT equipment; taken from Lenz, Ulrich; IT‐Systeme: Ausfallsicherheit im Kostenvergleich; 2007; www.cio.de/a/it‐systeme‐ausfallsicherheit‐im‐kostenvergleich,458076

A survey conducted in 2010, in which 182 people from small or mid‐sized retail and trade businesses participated, produced the results identified in the table below. Participants were asked how high they would evaluate operational damage in the case of total IT failure, depending on the duration of the failure.

In the case of a failure up to four hours, 50.3% of those surveyed estimated the damage to be between € 1000 and € 4999; 11.5% of those surveyed estimated the damage to an amount above € 19,999. For a failure of up to a week, 35.7% of those surveyed also estimated the damage to be above € 19,999.

[PLEASE INSERT EIN-20-Safety-2.jpg HERE]

Results of a survey of small and mid‐sized businesses (SMEs) and trade; taken from a study by ECC, NEG
Federal Ministry of Economics and Technology, Germany; Source: Statista GmbH, Statista GmbH, Johannes‐Brahms‐Platz 1, 20355 Hamburg, http://de.statista.com/; 2015.

Action planning

For a specific plan of actions that goes beyond minimum legal requirements for reducing the residual risk in low‐voltage switchgear assemblies, it is necessary to answer a key question: How great is the importance/significance of the low‐voltage switchgear assembly for the maintenance of operations and safety of employees working next to the switchgear assemblies (see Section 3)?

Responding to the following questions may help provide an answer to the above question.

  1. What are the technical impacts of a failure of a switchgear assembly?
  2. How high are the consequential damages; what does the damage interruption function look like?
  3. What are the possible effects of a failure of the switchgear assembly on the employees ensuring servicing? How are the preventative maintenance measures performed regularly to prevent failures and keep operating equipment in proper condition and servicing (e.g., repair, replacement of defective parts) carried out in practice?
  4. How great is the damage to the company’s image if delivery times cannot be kept? 5. What are the consequences of a switchgear assembly failure on the environment?

In Part 3: what’s involved in meeting employer responsibilities under workplace health and safety legislation, and six causes of arc faults in low‐voltage switchgear assemblies.

Alfred Mörx is the owner of diam‐consult, a consulting engineering office for physics focusing on risk analysis and protective technology in complex technical systems, since 2001. He studied technical physics at the Vienna University of Technology. As an expert for basic electrotechnical safety matters, he has been working in national, European, and international teams in the area of safe electricity application for more than 25 years; www.diamcons.com; am@diamcons.com. This article was previously published as an Eaton white paper

Read Part 1: http://www.electricalindustry.ca/latest-news/4202-safety-and-risk-in-electrical-low-voltage-installations-part-1

 

Changing Scene

  • Prev
  Eaton is pleased to announce the appointment of Rahul Duggal to the position of Product ...
Is it possible for the Ideal Nationals competition to be even more exciting? That question will be ...
The Solar Energy Society of Alberta and Energy Efficiency Alberta, in partnership with the ...
Nat will develop and execute on key sales strategies along with leading his team to drive strong ...
John MacDonald (better known as Satch) has decided that he will retire from Ideal Supply at the end ...
Aspiring skilled trades participants recently descended upon annual Skills Competitions held in ...
Join WiRE and partners 20/20 Catalysts Program and the Aboriginal Apprenticeship Board of Ontario ...
A new program launched by Nova Scotia with federal government support will provide rebates of up to ...
The National Electrical Contractor Association announced on June 18 that Southwire has been ...
Located 160 kilometres west of the Porcupine mine in Chapleau, Ontario, Borden is set to be ...

Electrician Forum Brought to you by Schneider Electric

As industry experts you know the products you use everyday better than anyone and should have input on what information you receive about products and what could improve them.

Therefore, we want your insight on the biggest challenges or issues you face when installing loadcentres, breakers (CAFI, GFI's…) and other surge protection devices. We ask that you do not provide product specific details but rather your general issues and concerns or any questions that have come to mind while working with these product types. Provide us with your valued expert insight into the issues you have faced so manufacturers can better inform you about the installation and use of these products. Lets generate some discussion that will help guide the Industry.

Make your comments  HERE

 

Codes and Regulations Brought to You by the CSA Group

  • Prev
In this article: Section 58 — Passenger Ropeways and Similar Equipment. Rule 58-000 ...
  Unauthorized CSA Group certification marks have been found on wiring by Triumph Cable ...
In this article: Section 52 — Diagnostic imaging installations. The CE code is a ...
In this article: Section 46 — Emergency Power Supply, Unit Equipment, Exit Signs, and ...
  In this article: Section 44 — Theatre Installations. The CE Code is a ...
CSA has published C22.2 No. 60947-7-3, the harmonized standard for low-voltage switchgear and ...
  Electric welders. The CE Code is a comprehensive document. Sometimes it can seem ...
  In this article: Section 40 — Electric cranes and hoists. The CE Code is a ...

 

Cloud

There has been a lot of talk about cloud computing and Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) models these days but both are relatively new to the lighting industry. Let’s take a look at what they are as well as their roles in commercial lighting.

What is cloud computing?

Cloud computing is the on-demand delivery of compute power, database storage, and applications via the Internet with pay-as-you-go or subscription-based pricing. Cloud computing means that instead of all the computer hardware, software, and data that you are using sitting somewhere inside your company’s network, it’s provided and managed for you as a service by another company and you access it over the Internet. 

Read More



Tools for the Trade

  • Prev
  IDEAL Industries has introduced Combination Drill Taps to its tool lineup. Combining the ...
  Stripping and crimping device, 100 - 240 V input voltage, for insulated ferrules with a ...
Professional all-in-one cutter/stripper for coaxial and twisted pair cables     ...
  Klein Tools' Coax Explorrer 2 tests coaxial cable and maps up to 4 locations   ...
  Ideal Industries' T-14 wire stripper s are ideal for all professionals working within the ...
  The ATS850 conveyor eliminates all types of electro static discharge requirements. ...
  Lorik Tool & Automation has the experience and ability to manufacture a variety of ...
  Ideal Industries' 26 piece insulated Journeyman kit is ideal for new electricians or for ...
  Klein Tools Deluxe Fish Rod Set comes in 19 pieces that when assembled can fish wire and ...
  BendWorks Software was designed to help electrical contractors adopt this new process ...

Product News

  • Prev
  Eaton has announced expanded fixtures, controls and accessories for its Halo ...
  The HALO Home Internet Access Bridge (Bridge) enables you to control your HALO Home ...
  The wireless receptacle is an integral part of the WaveLinx Wireless Connected Lighting ...
  The latest in label creation software,  Brady  Workstation has revolutionized ...
Brady’s new ToughStripe Max floor marking tape is ideal for high-traffic areas where sliding ...
  Strip, cut, twist, shear and crimp with one tool. Features four dedicated crimpers for B ...
  The ultimate in UL listed and CSA certified watertight, direct burial ...
  The IDEAL Stripmaster® Model 950™ Wire Stripper is an electrically operated, ...
   Arlington’s zinc MC cable fittings, for dry locations, are convenient and ...
  Suitable for installation in cable trays in dry, damp and wet locations or for direct ...

 

Peers & Profiles

  • Prev
David Johns is a unique and dedicated individual both at home and in the workplace. At home he is a ...
    Sean Freeman is a vibrant, enthusiastic and selfless individual who has taken his ...
  Automation companies are drivers of innovation, and have penetrated near every industry ...
Total Electrical Solutions was founded in 2013 by Jeremy Herrington in Quispamsis, on the outskirts ...
Andrew MacLeod is a territory sales manager with Leviton Manufacturing of Canada in British ...
  Floyd Lau founded Amptek Technologies in 2002 as an end to end engineering design ...
Mike Marsh, President and CEO of SaskPower, has been a leading figure in Saskatchewan’s ...
Gordon MacDonald is a cheerful, driven individual who loves to be challenged, a trait that suits ...
  Most of us have a difficult enough time managing one job and a home life. However, some ...
  Since 2012 Barnstormer has advanced the abilities of their brewery with the installation ...

Copper $US Dollar price per pound


 

Jean-Marc Myette

By Line Goyette

Meeting people in our industry often comes with surprises. This was the case with Jean-Marc Myette, Business Development Manager of ABB’s Electrification Products Division and chair of the Board of Electro-Federation Canada’s Quebec section. Not only does he know the electrical industry down to the most minute product and technological innovations, he is also a professional car racer on sabbatical, and someone very involved in his business community and personal life.

Read More

 

 

Kerrwil Publications

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2018 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil