6 Tactics to Maximize the Purchasing Function: Tactic 5 — Know Your Prices

Procurement

 

Dec 31 2015

 

Barry Olson

This article is the fifth in a series of six tactics in which the electrical contractor can maximize purchasing power and profitability though procurement. My last few tactics have dealt with various psychological and social behavioural hacks, which can work either in your favour or against it. This tactic is no different, but it is one of the most powerful tools I can suggest for you. It is based on a well-researched social behaviour phenomenon called anchoring, and here is how it works.

Suppose you ask your favourite distributor for a price on a new, never-before-offered electrical product, and they respond with a quoted price of $2,500. Since you have no prior exposure to this product, the distributor has anchored that figure in your mind. In the future, as you encounter that product or even a similar item, the $2,500 amount will become your established point of reference, and you will judge the value you are receiving against that dollar amount. This can be dangerous for you if you have no other information from which to evaluate pricing. It is important that you not only review pricing for the specific item but also pricing for an “equal” product. The inclusion of an equal helps give a comparative anchor, which will keep you from being anchored at a potentially higher level than the original item is actually worth.

The anchoring phenomenon, or biases as they are referred to, do not stop there but actually can affect other aspects of one’s cognitive reasoning. For instance, if you are given a price in even thousands, say $110,000, you are more likely to lean towards counteroffering in even thousands because your anchor is an even number divisible by 1,000. This is an important concept to understand as it can also help you negotiate a better price with your vendors. The trick is to offer your vendor an order based on the price you want to pay but with the amount listed to the nearest 10.
For instance, suppose you need to buy a lighting package for $260,000 (assume this is what you actually carried in your bid and was discounted from the best quote available at bid time). Offer your vendor the order at $238,520. This figure accomplishes two things: First, it anchors your vendors cost down to the 10-dollar realm, and they will be more likely to try to negotiate in smaller increments due to that subtle subconscious nudge. Second, vendors rarely accept your first offer of business, especially if the number is aggressive like the example above. By providing a non-traditional dollar amount, they will assume you have a reason for offering such a specific amount and are much more likely to attempt to actually reach the number you present.

This all may sound a bit far-fetched, but I have observed this strategy used very successfully for buyouts on many occasions.

Another part of this anchoring bias, it turns out, also primes one to think in relative terms. Researchers have demonstrated this effect by offering extreme anchor examples and then had study participants guess as to an actual value. As an example, researchers asked one group of people if they thought the average lifespan of a dolphin was more than two years and another group if a dolphin’s lifespan was less than 150 years. Both groups assume the real answer is to be found somewhere above the two-year mark and below the 150-year mark respectively. The interesting part is that the group given the lower anchor number tends to guess a lower average number, and the group given the higher anchor number tends to guess a higher average number. This discrepancy clearly demonstrates the power of the anchoring bias on most people and can be utilized to your advantage in certain scenarios.

How this can apply to you is rather simple. When discussing the value of a package with a vendor prior to a bid, refer to the bill of material using terms that invoke thoughts of low value. Using terms like “basic,” “value priced,” “cheap,” “commodity,” or any other descriptive term that identifies the bill of material as being of low value carries a priming effect. I have even suggested low-ball price figures to help anchor the perception that the price should be low. All of these suggestions help prime your vendor to expect a low price from the manufacturer’s agent. Remember, you are often working against the agent in such circumstances, and the mission of any agent is to uphold the amount they consider the market can bear in your geographical area. If your distributor has been primed or anchored sufficiently prior to receiving a price from the agent, the vendor will generally balk at the market price and ask for a better price before sending their quote to you.

This strategy, like any other, is not 100% effective all the time and on every person to which it is applied. It is based on the Western or Greek thought process, which categorizes, separates, and looks for patterns for comparison, and most readers of this article will fall into this category. That said, anchoring is a powerful tool you can use to your advantage under many circumstances; just be aware that the strategy, while soundly based on psychological principles, will vary in its effectiveness from person to person.

Barry Olson has 25 years of purchasing experience with large union contractors and is currently the director of purchasing for SASCO in Southern California. He holds a Bachelor’s degree in organizational leadership, is nearing completion of a Master’s degree in the same discipline, and plans to continue his studies with a Ph.D. Barry can be contacted at BarryOlson@Outlook.com.

This article has been reprinted with the permission of Electrical Contractor Magazine.

These articles originally appeared on ECmag.com in 2015. Next and last in the series: consistency and fairness.

Read More Articles on Electrical Industry Canada by this Barry Olson:

6 Tactics to Maximize the Purchasing Function: Tactic 1 — Economies of Scale

6 Tactics to Maximize the Purchasing Function: Tactic 2 — Pricing

6 Tactics to Maximize the Purchasing Function: Tactic 3 — Time

6 Tactics to Maximize the Purchasing Function: Tactic 4 — Influence

 

Related Articles


Latest Articles

  • Breaking out of a Winter Slowdown

    Breaking out of a Winter Slowdown

    March 10, 2025 For many Canadian electricians, winter months bring a painful slowdown in business. You’re grateful for your projects, but snowbanks, cold temperatures and slippery surfaces mean a half-day project eats up most of the day and the battery in your heated hoodie always seems to be on “empty”. Generate new business by strengthening… Read More…

  • How Technology is Reshaping Lighting Design: Augmented Reality, Sustainability, Smart Lighting, and 3D Printing

    How Technology is Reshaping Lighting Design: Augmented Reality, Sustainability, Smart Lighting, and 3D Printing

    March 10, 2025 By Kaitlin Burke, Lead System Engineer at Cooper Lighting Solutions & Rajat Bhayana, Lighting Product Manager at Cooper Lighting Solutions Technology is rapidly reshaping the lighting design industry, offering new ways to streamline workflows, enhance aesthetics, and optimize energy efficiency. In 2025, lighting professionals will have more tools than ever to balance… Read More…

  • A Powerful Partnership

    A Powerful Partnership

    March 10, 2025 By Milwaukee® Milwaukee® believes in the power of relationships. The global leader in hand tools and power tools has built its reputation over the past 100 years from the combination of producing high-quality tools designed for the jobsite, while continuing to go above and beyond their user’s expectations. A perfect example of… Read More…

  • ECAO Tariff Tracker

    ECAO Tariff Tracker

    March 7, 2025 ECAO is closely monitoring the evolving tariff battle between Canada and the US. ECAO are staying in touch with their industry partners and legal resources, and continually monitoring news feeds. In addition, they will be meeting with affiliate partners, suppliers and other industry players to plan implementation of possible solutions, to advise… Read More…


Changing Scene

  • IDEAL Electrical™ Unveils Fresh, Modern Brand Identity

    IDEAL Electrical™ Unveils Fresh, Modern Brand Identity

    March 7, 2025 IDEAL Electrical was the first company to obtain a patent to make and sell wire connectors in the United States 96 years ago this month – and today IDEAL® announces a modern look for the brand, which captures the company’s spirit of relentless innovation and the optimistic future of the electrical trade. … Read More…

  • Noramco Announce Promotion at London Branch

    Noramco Announce Promotion at London Branch

    March 7, 2025 Noramco has announced the promotion of Erika Liddle to Commercial & Industrial Account Manager – London. “Since joining us in September as Sales Support, Erika has embraced every challenge with determination, quickly making a strong impression. Her ability to learn, adapt, and build meaningful relationships with our customers has set her apart…. Read More…

  • Leviton Canada Unveils New Conveyor System at the Canadian DistributionCenter in Pointe-Claire, Quebec

    Leviton Canada Unveils New Conveyor System at the Canadian DistributionCenter in Pointe-Claire, Quebec

    March 7, 2025 Leviton Canada is thrilled to announce the unveiling of their new conveyor system at the Pointe-Claire (Quebec) distribution center, designed to boost efficiency and enhance service for their valued customers across Canada. With cutting-edge automation and improved accuracy, we’re ready to handle your orders faster and more reliably than ever before. This… Read More…

  • ESA President and CEO Named One of Canada’s Top Women in Safety

    ESA President and CEO Named One of Canada’s Top Women in Safety

    March 7, 2025 The Electrical Safety Authority (ESA) is proud to announce that Josie Erzetic, President and CEO at ESA, has been named one of Canada’s Top Women in Safety by the Canadian Occupational Safety (COS) magazine for 2025. The awards recognize exceptional female leaders who shatter glass ceilings while influencing the health and safety… Read More…