The Impact of Arc Flash Events on Photocontrol Longevity in LED Lighting

Lighting LED Control

The adoption of LED lighting continues at a rapid pace.Although the extended life of LEDs is beneficial, it also presents a compatibility challenge with older technology controls, especially with outdoor photocontrols. This rapid change to LED fixtures andluminaires can leave contractors, designers and distributors facing questions they cannot answer.

LED and other new lightingtechnologies exclusively useelectronic drivers and ballasts for operation. Their designshave different electrical start-up characteristics than older,magnetic models. In the case of photocontrols, matching theextended lifespan of LED fixtures requires a more complexcontrol unit for a reliable, turn-on/off.

Design considerations for electronic ballasts

A more complex control unit is required because some electronic ballasts produce inrush currents at turn-on that can cause premature relay contact failures. Intermatic has completed simulations in our UL-certified laboratory and has videotaped the phenomena of this spike of energy. This energy spike can and has caused control failures in the field.These inrush currents can be much higher than thoseexperienced with traditional tungsten or magnetic ballastloads because many electronic ballasts employ large energystorage capacitors. Such capacitors can charge up to 400Vfor a 277 V line voltage, and will briefly draw high currentfrom the line to achieve this voltage.

As mentioned above, these typically short inrush currentscan climb as high as 100-times the nominal operating levels.(See table below for typical inrush value comparisons.)

LED Control Table

An overlooked source of photocontrol failure

Inrush currents have not always been recognized as a source of failure for controls. Some contractors may mistakenly believe that a switch has failed because it’s a“bad” switch or a power surge has occurred. Jay Hoch, Lighting Specialist for Wyandotte Electric Supply, Wyandotte, Michigan, noticed photocontrol failures on a large, exterior LED lighting project in Detroit. “We had multiple fixtures on one circuit fail, but not all of the fixtures failed. That didn’t make any sense. If one failed, they all should.” Hoch was looking for an explanation and wondering how best to advise the contractor coming to him.Information on inrush currents supplied by Intermatic made sense of the performance of the controls that Hoch andthe contractor had noticed. After reviewing the information,Hoch realized that in rush currents were adversely impacting the controls. “The failure wasn’t in the circuit,” Hoch says.“Intermatic’s research solidified the fact that the in rushcurrent affects photo cells.”

Variances in inrush current

The inrush current magnitude and duration depends upon the value of the capacitance (measured inμF), along with circuit and power distribution network impedances.This current may weld relay contacts and other switching devices or possibly fuse semiconductors. Overall, these high-current transients can negatively impact the lifespan of traditional photo controls,negating the reduced maintenance cost associated with LED luminaires.

Therefore, the actual performance of electronic ballasts can’t be determined by a straight watt-to-watt comparison of incandescent bulbs to LED bulbs. At first glance, it may make sense to assume that ten 15 W LED bulbs could be substituted for a single 100 W incandescent bulb. However,an inrush current in the LEDs can negatively impact the control, causing failures over time.

If contractors don’t look at the specs for the controls, they may believe when a switch failsit’s a bad switch. However,providing proper control specifications would enable contractors to avoid failures that are caused by very highinrush currents.

New electronic ballast designs can provide low or zero in rush currents, but they are more costly to implement and have not been universally adopted by lighting manufacturers in the marketplace. This created a challenge for control suppliers. Hearing questions from distributors and contractors, Intermatic chose to design electronic photo controls for worst case in rush currents, as characterized bythe National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA)’s survey of electronic ballast technologies.

Read the Rest of the Series:
The Impact of Arc Flash Events on Photocontrol Longevity in LED Lighting – Part 2
The Impact of Arc Flash Events on Photocontrol Longevity in LED Lighting – Part 3


Source: Intermatic Incorporated, 7777 Winn Road, Spring Grove, IL 60081; 815-675-2321; www.intermatic.com/zerocross. Intermatic’s new line of electronic photocontrols for LED applications successfully utilizes zero crossing techniques to suppress inrush current impact and deliver on the extended lifespan of LED luminaires. As a result, Intermatic offers costeffective, 8 to 12 year warrantied electronic photocontrols, while providing large inrush current carrying capacities. Lab testing shows the visible reduction of inrush current, which Intermatic has captured on video.

 

Related Articles


Latest Articles

  • Ontario Drives Growth in Residential Building Construction in September

    Ontario Drives Growth in Residential Building Construction in September

    November 25, 2024 Investment in building construction rose 2.1% to $21.6 billion in September, following a 0.2% increase in August. The residential sector increased 2.9% to $15.2 billion in September, while the non-residential sector edged up 0.3% to $6.4 billion. Year over year, investment in building construction grew 6.7% in September. On a constant dollar basis (2017=100), investment in building construction increased 1.6% from… Read More…

  • Ontario’s Institutional Construction Intentions Push up the Non-Residential Building Permits in September

    Ontario’s Institutional Construction Intentions Push up the Non-Residential Building Permits in September

    November 25, 2024 The total value of building permits in Canada increased by $1.3 billion (+11.5%) to $13.0 billion in September, reaching the second-highest level since the start of the new series in January 2017. Ontario’s construction intentions grew by $1.2 billion (+25.0%) to $5.9 billion in September 2024, leading gains in both the non-residential and residential sectors. On a constant… Read More…

  • Red Seal Self-Assessment Questions

    Red Seal Self-Assessment Questions

    November 25, 2024 Each trade’s self-assessment tool is available to help you understand your own readiness for challenging the Red Seal exam in that trade. It goes through all topics that are included in the trade’s standard (Red Seal Occupational Standard/National Occupational Analysis) and asks you to reflect on whether you have the experience and knowledge in each… Read More…

  • Halifax Regional Municipality Seeking Deep Energy Retrofit Service Providers

    Halifax Regional Municipality Seeking Deep Energy Retrofit Service Providers

    November 25, 2024 Halifax Regional Municipality (HRM) is seeking qualified deep energy retrofit service providers to be added to its roster of approved contractors. Submit your response to be considered for future deep energy retrofit projects with HRM by the January 6 deadline. Go HERE for more information Read More…


Changing Scene

  • ITC Electrical Components Celebrates 30 Years of Service to the Electrical, Automation and OEM Market in Canada

    ITC Electrical Components Celebrates 30 Years of Service to the Electrical, Automation and OEM Market in Canada

    November 25, 2024 Celebrating its 30th anniversary, ITC Electrical Components has recently launched its new and improved website at www.itcproducts.com. After a successful 15-year career in the electrical components industry Luca Fontana founded ITC Electrical Components in 1994.  Since that time the company has grown from a home-based operation to a successful business with 15 employees and… Read More…

  • Eaton Canada Investing $15m to Expand Manufacturing Capacity

    Eaton Canada Investing $15m to Expand Manufacturing Capacity

    November 25, 2024 Eaton Canada is investing approximately $15 million to expand manufacturing capacity to meet growing demand for its electrical solutions driven by the ongoing electrification of Canada’s economy. These investments will expand the company’s low-voltage manufacturing footprint by 20%, increasing its ability to produce the switchboards, switchgear and panelboards needed to support Canada’s… Read More…

  • Bartle & Gibson Announces Partnership with Electric Avenue

    Bartle & Gibson Announces Partnership with Electric Avenue

    November 25, 2024 Bartle & Gibson Co. Ltd., a Western Canada-based premier plumbing, heating and electrical distributor, proudly announced a new regional partnership to distribute Electric Avenue, providers of convenient, affordable and easy-to-use smart charging solutions for residential and commercial use, across Western Canada. Electric Avenue was founded in 2021 with one simple mission: to… Read More…

  • Federal Investment to Add 989 New Montreal Homes

    Federal Investment to Add 989 New Montreal Homes

    November 18, 2024 The federal government is providing nearly $364 million to help build 989 new homes in Montreal. The announcement took place at 5200 rue de la Savane, in Montreal, which received $100 million dollars through the Apartment Loan Construction Program (ACLP) to build 303 homes and will be operated by Olymbec. This rental building, named Lynk, is designed to… Read More…