Understanding the Difference in Lumen Intensity — HID vs. LED

LED Tech

 

May 7, 2017

The modernization of lighting systems has generated a significant improvement of the energy efficiency. Thanks in large part to our industry’s innovative technologies, lighting products are more efficient while energy use has been reduced substantially. Following are a few definitions of lumen as well as some measurements based on various light source technologies.

Initial lumens

All light sources fade over time; light intensity diminishes to a point that it becomes inefficient, though it does not cease to function. When we first turn on a light, its luminosity is at its highest degree: this is called initial lumen. In the case of a LED light, we need to wait 45 minutes after initial lighting to measure this level as the diodes need time to stabilize. In the case of an HID light, the measurement is calculated after 1,000 hours of use. This process is called burn-in.

Lumen maintenance and L90/L70/L50 documents

Lumen maintenance is linked to the life span of a lamp or a luminary; in actual fact, a LED never ceases to function. In theory, it is everlasting, so long as there is an electrical current to feed it. The gradual fading of a light source’s intensity is what renders the lamp or luminaire obsolete.

In the case of lighting products that use an LED system, we refer to technical documents known as L90, L70 and L50, which calculate the life span of a LED luminaire’s circuit board in hourly increments. We estimate the amount of light that the diodes produce when this luminaire diffuses 90% (L90), 70% (L70) or 50% (L50) of the quantity of initial lumens. Actually, a 70% deterioration corresponds to the stage at which the human eye registers a decline in the intensity of light. The human eye will only be inconvenienced when light intensity reaches a level of 30%. So, when we state that a luminaire has a 72,000-hour lumen maintenance, it means that we can expect to notice a reduction of light intensity after 72,000 hours of use. However, this does not mean that the luminaire will cease to function.

LED Tech Charts

 Delivered lumens

The expression “delivered lumens” (or absolute lumens) describes the luminous flux generated by a lighting system when factoring in the optical loss factor of this system.

Conventional vs. LED lighting

In the case of conventional technologies, such as HID, only the lamp’s intensity is measured; optical loss is not taken into account. This is why we talk mainly about delivered lumens. In the case of LEDs, the luminaire is tested, in which case optical loss is considered as a factor. Thus, in the case of LED lighting, we refer to absolute lumens.

LED Chart 2

 When comparing the output of an HID light source to that of an LED light source, we examine a number of factors, such as the lifespan of the light source, the lumen maintenance over time, as well as optical loss (specifically for the HID light source). In other words, we measure the luminous flux of the HID lamp installed in a luminaire so as to measure its efficiency. This way, we can compare the delivered lumens of both light technologies.

This article was first published as a Standard’s online journal.

Related Articles


Latest Articles

  • Alberta Municipalities EV Charging Installation Rebate

    Alberta Municipalities EV Charging Installation Rebate

    April 4, 2025 Alberta Municipalities are proud to provide financial rebates for applicants to purchase and install electric vehicle charging stations in Alberta as part of the Electric Vehicle Charging Program (EVCP), funded by Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) & Alberta Municipalities.  The funding will cover up to 46% of your total project cost, which can… Read More…

  • Industry Legend Bill Smith Retires

    Industry Legend Bill Smith Retires

    April 4, 2025 By Electro-Federation Canada On March 25, Electrozad, a Sonepar Company, hosted a special retirement reception at Caesars Windsor for industry titan Bill Smith who marked an incredible 50-year career with the company.  The reception was held in the elegant Caesars Ballroom, which featured an array of food stations and elegant decor. In… Read More…

  • Schneider Electric: Your Trusted Partner in Sustainability and Efficiency

    Schneider Electric: Your Trusted Partner in Sustainability and Efficiency

    April 4, 2025 By Krystie Johnston Schneider Electric is on a mission to be the trusted partner in sustainability and efficiency. Since 1836, they have pioneered technological innovation to create a world where life is on. Frederick Morency, Vice President of Sustainability, Strategic Initiatives & Innovation at Schneider Electric Canada, has experienced this joie de… Read More…

  • The Evolving Landscape of Energy Management in Buildings with Trilliant’s Steven Lupo: AMI, EV Charging, DERs & Beyond Metering

    The Evolving Landscape of Energy Management in Buildings with Trilliant’s Steven Lupo: AMI, EV Charging, DERs & Beyond Metering

    March 31, 2025 By Blake Marchand Late last year Trilliant announced partnerships with Oshawa Power and Milton Hydro to enable suite metering and advanced metering technology using their Smart Building Platform. Those partnerships were the jumping off point for my conversation with Steven Lupo, Managing Director, North America at Trilliant, a company with four decades of innovation in Canada… Read More…


Changing Scene

  • NSAA Fee Change Effective April 1, 2025

    NSAA Fee Change Effective April 1, 2025

    As of April 1, 2025, the Nova Scotia Apprenticeship Agency’s fees have changed due to the 1% reduction in HST in Nova Scotia. NSAA noted on their website that due to the number of references across various pages, you may still come across old fee amounts as they work through updating their website. Here is… Read More…

  • Nominations Open for 2024 NETCO Leadership Excellence Award

    Nominations Open for 2024 NETCO Leadership Excellence Award

    Established in 2016, the NETCO Leadership Excellence award honours an industry training professional for his/her role for the success and their outstanding contributions to apprenticeship training and continuing electrical training. Read More…

  • Munded Partners with Kane Test Equipment in Atlantic Canada

    Munded Partners with Kane Test Equipment in Atlantic Canada

    April 4, 2025 Munden Enterprises has announced a partnership with Kane Test Equipment to bring their test and measurement solutions to Atlantic Canada. “We are now excited to announce a new and promising partnership with Kane Test Equipment. Kane Test Equipment brings innovative solutions that align with our dedication to providing the best tools for… Read More…

  • Nedco Announces Western Canadian Wire & Cable Sales Manager

    Nedco Announces Western Canadian Wire & Cable Sales Manager

    April 4, 2025 Don Blake has joined Nedco as their Western Canadian Wire & Cable Sales Manager. “With over 20 years of experience in the Wire & Cable industry, Don brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise to our Nedco West team,” said the company on LinkedIn. “His focus will be on expanding our product… Read More…