The Lumen Maintenance Gap

Lumens

October 3, 2018

This article is an excerpt from a technical brief, “Understanding LM-80, Lumen Maintenance, and LED Fixture Lifetime,” by Philips Color Kinetics.

Test results of lumen maintenance in conventional and LED light sources differ considerably. This is known as the lumen maintenance gap. These tests are performed to determine the useful life of a light source. But how do we compare lighting technologies satisfactorily if test results of a same designation do not mean the same thing? These lumen maintenance measurement distinctions are those we will examine in this article, as a clear understanding of this gap will have a significant impact on the installation, maintenance and replacement cost calculations of lighting products.

As an example of the benefits offered by lumen maintenance, the World Market Center in Las Vegas, Nevada (shown in photo), uses over 8,000 ft (2,438.4 m) of eW Cove Powercore linear LED lighting fixtures from Philips Color Kinetics to illuminate the complex geometries of the atrium in one of its buildings. LED cove lighting offers advantages over conventional cove lights in high-end installations such as this one. With useful life of up to 70,000 hours, and a very low failure rate, LED cove lights virtually guarantee reliable illumination around the clock for many years, without dark spots from lamp outages that can mar the elegant and uniform presentation of a premier space.

Lumen maintenance of LED and traditional light sources

When controlled, LED light sources can have a useful life that lasts considerably longer than the rated life of a conventional lighting source. Here’s an example: the World Market Center in Las Vegas, Nevada (shown in photo) uses over 8,000 ft (2,438.4 m) of eW Cove Powercore linear LED lighting fixtures from Philips Color Kinetics to illuminate the complex geometries of the atrium in one of its buildings. LED cove lighting offers advantages over conventional cove lights in high-end installations such as this one. With useful life of up to 70,000 hours, and a very low failure rate, LED cove lights virtually guarantee reliable illumination around the clock for many years, without dark spots from lamp outages that can mar the elegant and uniform presentation of a premier space.

The following table presents comparative data for the typical useful life range of various light sources.

Testing conventional light sources

LM-65-14 is a document that defines life testing procedures for compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs), while LM-49-12 defines life testing procedures for incandescent filament lamps. Both publications establish testing conditions, testing sample sizes, and valuation methods used for generalizing test data.

For CFLs, LM-65 specifies that a statistically valid sample be tested at an ambient temperature varying between 15⁰C and 40⁰C, in a cycle of three hours on and 20 minutes off (CFL life is appreciably shortened by the frequency with which the lamp is turned on and off). The point at which half the lamps fail is the rated average life for that lamp.

For incandescent filament lamps, LM-49 stipulates that a statistically valid sample be tested within the manufacturer’s stated operating temperature range and voltage. Lamps are turned off and allowed to cool to ambient temperature once a day (usually for 15 to 30 minutes). As with CFLs, rated life for incandescent filament lamps is the total operating time at which half the lamps cease to operate.

Lumen 2Testing conventional LED sources

As of 2014, the technical publication entitled LM-84-14 was introduced as a means to fill a gap created by the lack of standardized LED fixtures and lamps testing methods. Even today, the rated life is calculated according to tests performed on lighting system diodes and not on the overall lamp or fixture system. Unfortunately, at this point, the LM-84 publication has disclosed only light system test parameters and is unable to provide other calculation methodology to issue results that might establish a specific rated life.

Many fixture manufacturers develop their individual interpretation of the life test results and establish in their own way the useful life of light sources. Often, they do not share the extrapolation or evaluation methods, so any comparison between the products of various manufacturers becomes both difficult and imprecise.
Lumen 3

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Useful life is not fixture lifetime

It’s important to keep in mind that useful life and fixture lifetime are two very different things. The useful life of a fixture refers to the lumen maintenance projections of the LED sources integrated into that fixture — in plain English, the number of hours an LED lighting fixture will deliver a sufficient amount of light in a given application.

Fixture lifetime, on the other hand, has to do with the reliability of the components of an LED lighting fixture as a system, including the electronics, materials, housing, wiring, connectors, seals, and so on. The entire system lasts only as long as the critical component with the shortest life, whether that critical component is a weather seal, an optical element, an LED, or something else. From this point of view, LED light sources are simply one critical component among many, although they are often the most reliable component of the whole lighting system.

Read the full document here: www.colorkinetics.com/Learn/docs/LEDLifetime.pdf

Related Articles


Latest Articles

  • CAGE CLAMP®: The Connection Technology that Changed Industrial Wiring

    CAGE CLAMP®: The Connection Technology that Changed Industrial Wiring

    November 13, 2026 Nearly 50 years after its introduction, WAGO’s universal spring-pressure technology continues to influence electrical connection reliability, installation efficiency, and equipment design. A single loose electrical connection can stop a production machine, disable a control system, or send a technician searching through hundreds of terminations for the source of a fault. In equipment… Read More…

  • Revit Files – What Are They & Why Do They Matter?

    Revit Files – What Are They & Why Do They Matter?

    November 13, 2026 By Liteline What Is a Revit File? A Revit file is a Building Information Modeling (BIM) object. It’s a digital version of a product that carries shape and data. Unlike standard, static 3D models, a Revit file is parametric. This means it’s packed with information like the product’s performance and specification data.… Read More…

  • Daylight Harvesting & Occupancy Control – The Savings the Lamp Swap Left Behind

    Daylight Harvesting & Occupancy Control – The Savings the Lamp Swap Left Behind

    October 6, 2026 By Nedco Daylight Harvesting & Occupancy Control: Where the Meaningful Energy Story Now Sits Part one of a three-part series on where energy savings live now that the LED conversion is essentially over. For the better part of a decade, energy-efficient lighting and switch to LED meant the same thing. Rip out… Read More…

  • LEDVANCE: Toyota Lighting Case Study – Brossard, Quebec, Canada

    LEDVANCE: Toyota Lighting Case Study – Brossard, Quebec, Canada

    November 10, 2026 Located 15 minutes from Montreal, Toyota’s Quebec Regional Office in Brossard, Canada houses a first-floor training and service area, and second-floor offices where financial services and dealer network operations are conducted. LEDVANCE Toyota Case Study Overview Goal: To upgrade the outdated mix of metal halide, T8 and T5 fluorescent, compact fluorescent, and… Read More…


Changing Scene

  • Paula Irwin of Black & McDonald Receives 2026 CAWIC DEI Award

    Paula Irwin of Black & McDonald Receives 2026 CAWIC DEI Award

    November 13, 2026 Black & McDonald is proud to celebrate Paula Irwin, recipient of the 2026 Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) Award presented by the Canadian Association of Women in Construction (CAWIC). The award recognizes individuals who are making a meaningful contribution to advancing diversity, equity and inclusion within the construction industry. In announcing the… Read More…

  • Electrical Safety Authority and London Hydro Partner to Tackle Copper Theft and Protect Ontario Communities

    Electrical Safety Authority and London Hydro Partner to Tackle Copper Theft and Protect Ontario Communities

    November 13, 2026 The Electrical Safety Authority (ESA) and London Hydro have partnered to launch Copper Theft Toolkit: Understanding Safety Risks and Community Impacts, a free communications toolkit developed collaboratively to help communities recognize the dangers, raise awareness and safely report suspicious activity. Copper theft is an ongoing safety concern that puts Ontarians at risk,… Read More…

  • Supporting Enoch Cree Nation’s Long-Term Housing Strategy and Community Growth

    Supporting Enoch Cree Nation’s Long-Term Housing Strategy and Community Growth

    November 9, 2026 The Canada Infrastructure Bank (CIB) has reached financial close on a $30 million loan towards enabling infrastructure for critical housing development on ECN reserve lands, near Edmonton, Alberta. The project will address exponential housing pressures within the community, allowing ECN members to return to community while supporting long-term growth on reserve.  The… Read More…

  • BCCSA Invests $100,000 to Strengthen BC’s Future Construction Workforce

    BCCSA Invests $100,000 to Strengthen BC’s Future Construction Workforce

    November 5, 2026 The British Columbia Construction Association (BCCA) is pleased to recognize a generous $100,000 contribution from the BC Construction Safety Alliance (BCCSA) Research, Development, and Opportunity Fund (RDO Fund) in support of Honour the Work, a national initiative dedicated to introducing young people to the skilled trades and building awareness of career opportunities… Read More…