Canadian Electrical Industry News Week

Oct 19, 2020

Terry BeckerBy Terry Becker

I was reminded again over the past few weeks in working with clients on electrical safety program development, following up on LinkedIn posts, and reviewing IEEE 1584 based arc flash hazard incident energy analysis study P.Eng. reports for clients that industry doesn’t understand the CSA Z462 Workplace electrical safety standard and has been misinformed in P.Eng. arc flash hazard incident energy analysis study reports issued to them. Arc flash training or arc flash awareness training that employers have sent their qualified electrical workers and task qualified workers to has been fear based and instructed by someone who is not a CSA Z462 subject matter expert.

I will start with the IEEE 1584 Guide for Performing Arc-Flash Hazard Calculations standard. IEEE 1584 was first issued in 2002, and the formulas presented for calculating incident energy and the arc flash boundary applied to three phase 208VAC to 15kVAC electrical equipment. The second edition of IEEE 1584 was published in November 2018. The updated IEEE 1584 still only applies to three phase 208VAC to 15kVAC electrical equipment, but includes new more complex formulas and additional parameter selections that if conservatively interpreted can result in a 200% increase in calculated incident energy levels. Some of the problems with and misinformation and myths presented in study reports include the following:

1. The consulting firms used do not have an internal technical specification for studies and report content used across Canada in all of their offices. QA/QC and consistency of the power system study method used, IEEE 1584 2018 Edition parameter selection and report content are not completed.

2. The P.Eng. report issued is not complete, not detailed enough, doesn’t substantiate the requirements of the power system study (e.g. short circuit, protection and coordination and incident energy analysis), and includes errors and omissions.

3. The report issued drowns the client in hundreds of pages of default reports generated by the power system software.

4. The report appendices are not complete.

5. The report advises that 40 cal/cm2 of incident energy is “Dangerous,” “No PPE Exists.” This is not true.

6. When incident energy calculations are completed arc flash PPE is specified with an HRC # or an Arc Flash PPE Category # in the report issued. This is technically incorrect.

7. The report issued includes misquotes of CSA Z462 policy, practice or procedural requirements when the report should NOT include any of this content. Instead, the report should present incident energy and arc flash boundary distance calculations only. The employer is responsible for establishing and implementing policy, practices and procedural requirements based on the CSA Z462 Workplace electrical safety standard in an electrical safety program. The electrical engineer who issued the report is most likely not a CSA Z462 subject matter expert.

8. The P.Eng. who issued the report is not aware of the IEEE 1584.1 Guide for the Specification of Scope and Deliverable Requirements for an Arc-Flash Hazard Calculations Study in Accordance with IEEE standard, which can be used to audit their processes and report content.

9. The report includes PDF examples of non-compliant arc flash and shock equipment labels.

10. The 2-second rule was not applied.

11. No explanation and substantiation were provided for the new IEEE 1584 2018 Edition parameters (e.g. box/electrode configuration).

Unfortunately arc flash and shock training provided since 2005 has not been compliant, was and is fear based, and was not delivered by a CSA Z462 subject matter expert. The arc flash and shock training focussed more on arc flash and neglected the shock hazard: too many stories told and not enough training on the CSA Z462 standard. The training also miscommunicated that 40 cal/cm2 of incident energy was “Dangerous” and “No PPE Exists.” The training didn’t include content on the CSA Z462 mandatory “Risk Assessment Procedure,” and misinformed the student of when an energized electrical work permit (EEWP) would be required. The training didn’t effectively communicate how to apply the training in the workplace. An energized electrical job safety planning form example was not provided to the students. The training didn’t include a final test.

Figure 1 – Electrical Hazard Risk Assessment Matrix 3 X 3

Safety Figure 1





















Employers are not “Getting It Right!” What most employers have missed is that developing and implementing a compliant electrical safety program is the solution. A compliant electrical safety program would control all of the issues listed above and more. Documenting policies, practices and procedural requirements and providing electrical safety program orientation roll out training to qualified electrical workers and task qualified workers ensure that the generic arc flash and shock training can be properly applied in the workplace and the supervisor can validate electrical safety competency.

There is a lot of work yet to be done to ensure workers are not exposed to the arc flash and shock hazards in the workplace, and when they are they have applied the hierarchy of risk control methods to reduce risk to as low as reasonably practical.

Getting it right is accomplished by ensuring top down hierarchy of risk control methods are implemented through the application of a compliant electrical safety program. Use the electrical safety program to control the information your company receives! Put appropriate focus on the electric shock hazard. Do not accept what you think may be questionable information included in P.Eng. stamped arc flash hazard incident energy analysis reports, and ensure you control the specification of the arc flash and shock warning and danger signal pane equipment labels. As a supervisor, attend the arc flash and shock training with your workers so you can control the interpretation of what the instructor tells the students, and ask the instructor to substantiate their comments. Do not accept fear based language or communication from the instructor. To ensure that the quality and performance of arc flash and shock PPE your company procures meets industry conformance standards, ask for proof of ASTM F1959 test results.

It is in all of our best interests that when it comes to electrical hazards we “Get it Right!”

Figure 2 — Hierarchy of Risk Control Methods

Safety Figure 2
















If you wish to discuss any of the comments above, please do not hesitate to contact me, or by phone 1-587-433-3777.

Terry Becker, P.Eng., CESCP, IEEE Senior Member is the first past Vice-Chair of the CSA Z462 Workplace electrical safety Standard Technical Committee and currently a Voting Member and Working Group Leader for Clause 4.1 and the Annexes. Terry is also a Voting Member on the CSA Z463 Maintenance of electrical systems Standard and a Voting Member of the IEEE 1584 Guide for Performing Arc-Flash Hazard Calculations. Terry has presented at Conferences and Workshops on electrical safety in Canada, the USA, India, and Australia. Terry is a Professional Engineer in AB, BC, SK, MN and ON. Terry is an Electrical Safety Specialist, Management Consultant at TW Becker Electrical Safety Consulting Inc. and can be reached at 1-587-433-3777 or by email

Salex Announces Promotion of Paul Manson to GTA Sales Manager     

Paul MansonJanuary 26, 2021 – Salex, a facilitator of commercial lighting installations and control systems for Canada’s architectural lighting community, is excited to announce the promotion of Paul Manson to GTA Sales Manager. Paul joined Salex back in 2015, and has over 25 years of invaluable industry experience.

Dedicated to the education and promotion of quality, high-efficiency lighting and controls, Manson’s extensive background in on-site electrical installation, national accounts, relationship building, manufacturers, and sales team management at Philips Lighting, will provide valuable experience to fulfill his new role.

Read More


Changing Scene

  • Prev
ABB is hosting a Smart Building thought leadership session with six webinars presented by industry ...
Dimonoff and Amotus are proud to announce the merger of their entities under the same banner with ...
 EWEL has announced the plan to move its Sherwood Park branch into a brand-new facility at ...
Energy Savings for Business supports local skilled trades, contractors, and suppliers such as HVAC ...
Eaton has signed an agreement to acquire Tripp Lite, a supplier of power quality products and ...
Rexel announced it has acquired the Canadian Utility business of WESCO International (WESCO Canada ...
This questionnaire is designed for people who work in the electrical industry as part of a project ...
Organizers behind the MEET (Mechanical Electrical Electronic Technology) Show have announced its ...
Be sure not to miss your opportunity to participate at EDIST 2021 The Power of Resiliency, January ...
Teledyne Technologies Incorporated and FLIR Systems, Inc.jointly announced that they have entered ...






Canadian Electrical Contractor Discussion Group: Can You Count the Deficiencies?

EIN CECD 400Have you ever been called to fix the work of a 'handyman'?

"Was supposedly done by a"certified ' electrician....told the homeowner that he got a $266 record at TSBC. Can you count the deficiencies?"

"There is a second panel change in the triplex also.......even more deficiencies. Think the guy was a glorified handyman. Ones not obvious: 240 BB heat hooked up 120....drier on 2p20....range on 2p50....water heater fed with 2c14 Bx on 2p15."

Go HERE to join the discussion



DimonoffDimonoff and Amotus are proud to announce the merger of their entities under the same banner with the objective of offering a new range of tailor-made IoT products and services. Acquired by Dimonoff in 2018, Amotus has built a custom electronic and software development offering for interconnected solutions.

Composed of engineers and programmers, Amotus has completed more than 100 service projects in 15 countries with invoices ranging from $10,000 to $500,000. 



Read More


Ron TellasBy Ron Tellas

Disruptive technology alters the way we operate, driving us to improve processes, operations and systems. 

We're always watching for changes that will impact the industry and bring new possibilities to the way our networks and cabling and connectivity infrastructure are designed and deployed. We rounded up a short list of four technology disruptions that Belden is monitoring closely and think you should be, too.



Read More


Lighting SignifyBy Martin Garner

The Internet of Things (IoT) can help create safer workspaces, and connected lighting systems are uniquely well-placed to form the basis of an IoT infrastructure.

As the world starts to emerge from the COVID-19 pandemic, building owners, building managers, and office managers all have the urgent task of ensuring that workplaces offer employees a safety net from the virus. It’s not only important to make workspaces safe, but also to make people feel safe.


Read More


Product News

  • Prev
Champion Strut is a fiberglass non-metallic channel framing system that includes a complete ...
The PowPak 20 A Relay Receptacle Control Module is a radio-frequency (RF), receptacle switching ...
Occupancy sensor turns ON in low light only and when motion is detected. Turns off after 1 minute ...
Innovative Design for Versatile Applications. Easy to lock horizontally into place with a ...
NightFox Pro Series Photocontrols offer protection to typical, enhanced, or extreme electrical ...
The UHB LED is a round high bay luminaire designed for a variety of mounting heights and customer ...
When designing lighting for a space, why not consider a luminaire that can also solve an often ...
MaxLite expands their RCF Series with wattage and CCT selectable models that enable installers to ...
The Lithonia Lighting® TWX LED family has been re-invented from the ground up, delivering ...
LBR is everything you need in a retrofit downlight at an affordable price. Whether it’s the ...


Champion Strut Conduit and Pipe SupportChampion Strut is a fiberglass non-metallic channel framing system that includes a complete line of non-metallic accessories, fasteners, hangers, pipe clamps and channels.

Champion Strut™ is a versatile, high-strength fiberglass framing system that has been successfully used in many highly corrosive applications including steel mills, wastewater treatment, rendering facilities, utilities, refineries, chemical plants, marinas, pulp and paper, desalination facilities, water reclamation facilities, theme parks, aquariums, pools and underground vaults.


Read More


Intermatic NightFoxNightFox Pro Series Photocontrols offer protection to typical, enhanced, or extreme electrical transients as laid out by ANSI C136.2.

• ELC model safeguards applications against 6kV/3kA surge events or a typical level per ANSI C136.2
• EK and LED models provide protection for increased levels per ANSI C136.2
• Customers have the option of setting an extreme level of protection at 20kV/10kA transients per ANSI C136.2 – by requesting a larger 1020J MOV component


Read More



MaxLite Canless Commercial DownlightMaxLite expands their RCF Series with wattage and CCT selectable models that enable installers to customize light outputs and color temperatures in the field.

The RCF is a labor-saving, all-in-one solution for adding recessed downlighting to hospitality, retail, office, and other commercial lighting applications. The downlight features a built-in driver and integral whip that can be connected directly to a junction box, eliminating the need for a traditional recessed housing. 



Read More


Peers & Profiles

  • Prev
“It was quite surprising,” said Stephanie Smith of being named EHRC’s Leader of the Year. ...
As an advanced networked lighting controls company serving the industrial and large commercial ...
Trilliant, an international provider of utility solutions for advanced metering and smart grid ...
For more than a century, ABB has been investing in Canadian technologies and products to support ...
Mackenzie Gillan, a bright young lady from Baysville, Ontario, tells us about how she learned ...
Energy Efficient Lighting is a LED lighting manufacturer with nearly 30 years of industry ...
Dee Durant is an industrial electrician apprentice attending Conestoga College and an Ambassador ...
ECAO recently launched a new program called Future Leaders Advisory Council (FLAC). Their inaugural ...
At 14, Tom Miguel was sitting in the counselor’s office of Silverthorn Collegiate Institute in ...
Meredith Halfpenny is a Wind Site Technician with Boralex where she inspects, maintains, and ...

Stephanie SmithBy Blake Marchand

“It was quite surprising,” said Stephanie Smith of being named EHRC’s Leader of the Year. “Leadership in 2020 has certainly been a challenge for everybody in the world let alone the nuclear industry or the electricity industry.”

An engineer by trade, Smith spent the majority of her career with Ontario Power Generation (OPG). She was the first woman to be certified by the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission at the Pickering Nuclear Generating Station where she served as Plant Manager and was recently named the first President and CEO of CANDU Owners Group. Smith is also a passionate advocate for diversity and inclusion.

Read More


Copper $US Dollar price per pound

Kerrwil Publications Great Place to Work. Certified December 2019 - December 2020

538 Elizabeth Street, Midland,Ontario, Canada L4R2A3 +1 705 527 7666
©2021 All rights reserved

Use of this Site constitutes acceptance of our Privacy Policy (effective 1.1.2016)
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Kerrwil